Best Non-Candy Halloween Treats for School & Trunk or Treat

Who says Halloween has to be all about sugar highs and chocolate-covered chaos?

Sometimes the best surprises come in the form of non-candy Halloween treats that make kids smile just as big as a king-sized candy bar.

From glow sticks that light up the night to silly toys, crafts, and even snack packs that save the day, these goodies are proof that spooky season fun doesn’t have to come wrapped in foil.

This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my blog!

They’re perfect for trick-or-treat bags, classroom swaps, trunk or treat events, church fall festivals, Halloween parties, and handing out at home when you want something different from another handful of candy.

Non-candy treats are also a great option for kids with food allergies or dietary restrictions, and they give everyone something fun to take home without adding another mountain of sugar to the Halloween haul.

---

More Halloween Treat Ideas

Need even more fun ways to make Halloween handouts extra cute? These ideas are perfect for classrooms, parties, trick-or-treaters, and little neighborhood surprises.

🎃 Free Halloween Treat Bags – Four cute printable bags make even simple candy or small toys feel extra festive.

👻 Halloween Treat Bag Tags & Toppers – Dress up candy, snacks, and little favors with printable tags, labels, and toppers.

🕸️ Free Halloween Party Printables – Find tons of printable favor tags, treat boxes, decorations, and party extras.

🍭 Halloween Finger Foods & Treats – Get loads of fun Halloween food ideas for parties, school events, and fall

---

Non-Candy Treats for Trunk or Treat and Church Fall Festivals

If you’re filling a trunk for a trunk or treat or setting up a booth at a church fall festival, inexpensive non-candy prizes can be even easier than handing out candy.

Glow sticks, stickers, pencils, temporary tattoos, slap bracelets, bubbles, mini Play-Doh, and small toys are easy to buy in bulk and quick to hand out when there’s a line of excited kids waiting.

Glow sticks are especially fun for evening church fall festivals and trunk or treat events. My “Shine His Light” glow stick cards with either a cross or a Jack O’ Lantern turn a simple glow stick into an easy faith-based fall festival favor kids can take home.

For church events that skip the spooky side of Halloween, pumpkins, fall leaves, apples, friendly ghosts, and harvest-themed favors also work really well.

---

Cheap Non-Candy Halloween Treats to Buy in Bulk

When you’re expecting 50, 100, or even 200 kids, the cute little $3 favor suddenly doesn’t look quite so cute anymore.

For large trunk or treat events, school parties, neighborhood trick-or-treaters, and fall festivals, look for bulk Halloween treats that are inexpensive, easy to hand out, and don’t require a ton of assembly.

Some of the best options to buy in bulk include:

• Glow sticks and glow bracelets
• Spider rings
• Halloween pencils
• Stickers
• Temporary tattoos
• Slap bracelets
• Mini bubbles
• Bouncy balls
• Vampire teeth
• Pop-it toys

A simple printable tag can also make an inexpensive bulk toy feel much more special without adding a lot of extra work.

---

🎃 The List of Non-Candy Halloween Treats

Small Toys & Trinkets

• Glow sticks / glow bracelets – “You light up the night!” Perfect for trick-or-treating safety and a fun little party favor.

I have several printable Halloween glow stick cards and tags that make these super easy for classrooms, parties, and trick-or-treat favors.

• Mini bubbles – “Have a boo-tiful bubble time!” Always a hit, plus they keep kids entertained for hours.
• Vampire teeth – “Bite into some fun!” A Halloween classic kids never get tired of.
• Mini slime tubs / putty – Slime is still magic to kids. Try “Have a doh-tally awesome Halloween,” “Frankly, you’re doh best,” or “Have a won-doh-ful Halloween.”
• Halloween pencils – “Write on, ghoul friend!” Great for classrooms and homework motivation.
• Erasers – “Mistakes be gone, like magic!” Bonus points if they’re shaped like ghosts or pumpkins.
• Finger puppets – “A little boo on your finger!” Tiny, adorable, and silly fun.
• Halloween stickers – “Stick around for more fun!” Easy to hand out and perfect for parties.
• Mini stampers – “Stamp out the scares!” Kids love stamping everything in sight.
• Plastic bugs / creepy crawlies – “A little creepy, a lot of fun!” Gross factor = high kid approval.
• Pop-it toys – “Hope your Halloween is popping!”
• Bouncy balls – Cheap, colorful, and easy to toss into treat bags.
• Mini fidget toys – A great alternative for kids who already have plenty of candy.
• Sticky hands – Slightly ridiculous, slightly sticky, completely irresistible to kids.
• Mini puzzles or maze games – A fun little treat that keeps kids busy longer than five seconds.
• Mochi squishies – Tiny, cute, and easy to buy in bulk.
• Finger lights – Another fun option for nighttime trick-or-treating or fall festivals.
• Mini kaleidoscopes – A fun little throwback toy that works well for younger kids.

Wearables

• Plastic necklaces – A fun little wearable treat that’s easy to hand out at parties, classrooms, or trunk or treat events.

My Frankenstein favor card says “You’re Electric!” and turns a simple necklace into a cute ready-to-give Halloween favor.

• Fun sunglasses – “Throw shade like a vampire!” Imagine a room full of mini Count Draculas.
• Slap bracelets – “Slappy Halloween!”
• Spider rings – “Creepin’ it real!” Cheap, cheerful, and endlessly spooky.

Turn those inexpensive spider rings into a finished favor with my printable Halloween spider ring favor tags.

• Witch or bat headbands – “Top off your boo-tiful look!” Perfect photo ops for parties.
• Mini hats or masks – “Mask your true ghoul!” Kids love dress-up, so why not Halloween mini-style?
• Halloween hair clips or scrunchies – Especially fun for classroom exchanges or party favors.
• Novelty keychains – Small, inexpensive, and easy to add to a treat bag.
• Temporary tattoos – “Stick with the Halloween spirit!” Kids love them, parents don’t mind them. Win-win.

Art & Craft Supplies

• Crayons – “Color your night spooky!” Hand them out in Halloween colors for extra fun.
• Mini coloring books / activity pads – “A treat you can doodle with!” Perfect for classrooms.
• Washi tape strips – “Stick to the Halloween fun!” Colorful, crafty, and super practical.
• Mini Play-Doh tubs – “Mold some monster magic!” Hours of play in one tiny tub.
• Foam craft kits – “Craft your fright tonight!” Keep kids busy long after the candy’s gone.
• Scratch-art cards – Small, flat, and easy to hand out.
• Mini sticker sheets – Kids can use them for notebooks, water bottles, cards, and crafts.
• Paint-your-own wooden shapes – A fun option for classroom parties or fall festivals where kids have time to sit and make something.

Practical but Fun

• Mini notebooks – “A note-worthy treat!” Always handy for doodles or “top secret” kid notes.
• Mini hand sanitizer bottles – “Scare away the germs!” Parents will silently thank you.
• Chapstick / lip balm – “A little boo for your lips!” Fun themed ones are easy to find.
• Cute bandages – “Patch up your boo-boos!” Kids love to stick these on—even without a scrape.
• Bookmarks – An especially good choice for school parties, libraries, and church fall festivals.
• Halloween joke cards – A fun, flat treat that costs very little to make.

Snacks: Non-Candy but Still Yummy

• Mini bags of chips or pretzels – “A salty snack for your spooky sack!” Perfect for balancing out all the sweets. Or try “Chip or Treat!”
• Popcorn packs – “Pop into some fun!” Bonus points if they’re Halloween-themed.
• Granola bars – “A spook-tacular pick-me-up!” Easy to toss into lunchboxes, too.
• Animal crackers or Goldfish – “Snack like a little monster!” Always a kid favorite. For Goldfish: “Have a fin-tastic Halloween!”
• Mini cookie snack packs – “A boo-tiful bite!” Sweet, but not candy.
• Mini Donuts

---

Non-Candy Halloween Treats FAQs